LIVE CALCULATOR / PRICING VERIFIED NOV 2026 / 5 PLATFORMS · ZERO BIAS

Newsletter True-Cost Switcher

See what you actually keep after subscriber tier jumps, platform revenue cuts, and real Stripe processing fees, side by side.

Substack: $0 base fee, but drains 10% of gross revenue forever.
beehiiv & Ghost: 0% cut on paid subs with fixed base tiers.
Kit Commerce: 3.5% + $0.30 includes Stripe processing.
Front-Page Verdict BEST VALUE

Calculating your lowest-cost home...

Annual Savings vs. Substack $0 per year kept
Winner All-In Cost $0 $0/mo effective
Explore Winner

100% neutral math. Some links earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Winner Take-Home Split $0/yr gross
You Keep (Net) $0 (0%)
Platform Base + Cut $0 (0%)
Stripe Processing $0 (0%)
Visual Break-Even Curve ANNUAL ALL-IN COST ($)
Hover or drag chart to inspect
Calculating crossover points...
Real-Time Cost Rankings ANNUALIZED TOTAL

Itemized Fee Receipts & Hidden Gotchas

Exact monthly cost breakdown plus free-tier caps, branding locks, and fine print in plain English.

2026 Platform Break-Even Guides

Neutral head-to-head math showing the exact paid subscriber count where switching saves money.

Pricing Methodology & Verification

Every number on this page runs 100% locally in your browser from a single transparent pricing table last verified on November 20, 2026.

True Annual Cost = (Base Tier × 12) + Platform Revenue Cut + Stripe Fees
  • Subscriber Tier Brackets: Base monthly software costs step up automatically based on your Total Subscribers (free + paid combined), matching how beehiiv, Kit, Ghost(Pro), and MailerLite bill.
  • Auto-Upgrade Rule: If you enter 1 or more paid subscribers on a platform whose free plan forbids paid tiers (like beehiiv Launch), we automatically switch it to the lowest qualifying paid tier and flag the row.
  • Real Stripe Math: When Stripe is toggled ON, we apply 2.9% + $0.30 card processing plus 0.7% Stripe Billing recurring fee (3.6% + $0.30 total) on Substack, beehiiv, Ghost(Pro), and MailerLite.
  • Kit Commerce Bundling: Kit charges a single 3.5% + $0.30 fee that includes card processing. When Stripe is toggled OFF to compare pure platform fees, we isolate Kit's 0.6% markup above standard 2.9% card processing.

Frequently Asked Questions

At how many paid subscribers is Substack more expensive than beehiiv or Ghost?

Because Substack takes 10% of every paid dollar while beehiiv and Ghost(Pro) take 0%, the crossover happens faster than most writers expect. At $8/month, Substack typically passes Ghost(Pro) around 35–50 paid subscribers and passes beehiiv Scale around 55–85 paid subscribers (depending on your total free list size and whether you pay annually).

Does Kit charge Stripe fees on top of its 3.5% + $0.30 fee?

No. Kit Commerce bundles standard Stripe processing inside its 3.5% + $0.30 fee. You are never double-charged 2.9% + $0.30 on top, which makes Kit surprisingly competitive for small-to-medium paid newsletters that still fit inside its generous 10,000-subscriber free Newsletter tier.

Why do Stripe fees add up to 3.6% + $0.30 on Substack, beehiiv, and Ghost?

Standard US card processing on Stripe is 2.9% + $0.30 per charge. Recurring newsletter memberships also run through Stripe Billing, which adds 0.7% on recurring volume, bringing realistic payment processing to 3.6% + $0.30 per monthly subscriber charge.

Which platform is cheapest if my newsletter is 100% free?

Substack stays $0/month for unlimited free subscribers. Kit is free up to 10,000 subscribers (with basic automations), beehiiv is free up to 2,500 subscribers, and MailerLite is free up to 500 subscribers. Ghost(Pro) does not offer a free plan (though open-source Ghost can be self-hosted on a ~$6–$10/mo VPS).

Can I run paid subscriptions on beehiiv's free Launch plan?

No. beehiiv requires upgrading to at least the Scale plan to enable paid subscriptions and custom domains, and the Max plan if you want to strip beehiiv branding completely. Our calculator flags this automatically whenever you add paid subscribers.

Do I lose paid subscribers if I migrate off Substack?

No: your billing relationships live inside your own Stripe account, not locked inside Substack. When moving to beehiiv, Ghost(Pro), or Kit, you export your CSV list and connect the same Stripe account so active renewals continue uninterrupted without forcing readers to re-enter credit cards.